Advertising Sponsored by BB Company, Makers of Provitalize and Slim Gut
As women age, maintaining strong bones becomes essential—especially after 40, when bone density naturally begins to decline during menopause.
Having weaker bones don’t just mean a higher chance of fractures—they can also impact mobility, posture, and overall quality of life.
That’s why getting enough calcium isn’t just a good idea; it’s a necessity.
But not all calcium supplements are created equal. The right one can support bone strength and density, while the wrong one might be ineffective—or worse, difficult for your body to absorb.
So, how much calcium do you really need? And which forms are the most effective? Let’s break it down.
Source | Absorption Rate | Additional Minerals | No / Little Side Effects | |
| Marine Calcium *Winner* | Marine Algae | High (up to 70%) |  | |
| Calcium Carbonate | Limestone/Rocks | Moderate (40%) |  | |
| Calcium Citrate | Lab-Synthesized | Good (50%) | | |
What is it:
Calcium derived from specialized marine algae that naturally absorb and transform minerals from seawater.
These algae are sustainably harvested from pristine ocean waters and undergo minimal processing to preserve their natural mineral matrix. The resulting calcium is essentially “pre-digested” by the algae, contributing to its high bioavailability.
Why it’s better:
Studies show marine calcium can improve bone mineral density more effectively than traditional calcium supplements, with fewer side effects.1
What is it:
The most common calcium supplement, made from ground limestone or other rock sources.
Calcium carbonate is primarily mined from limestone quarries or obtained from crushed marble and chalk. The raw materials undergo extensive processing, including crushing, washing, and purification.
Good points:
Drawbacks:
What is it:
A calcium supplement created by combining calcium with citric acid. Unlike the other forms, calcium citrate is largely manufactured in laboratory settings rather than extracted from natural sources.
Good points:
Drawbacks:
Calcium doesn’t work alone. Think of vitamin D3 as the doorway that lets calcium into your bloodstream, while K2 acts as the traffic director that sends calcium to your bones instead of your arteries.
A good calcium supplement should include:
Without K2, calcium can build up in places where you don’t want it, potentially increasing health risks rather than reducing them.
Since calcium supplementation is generally a long-term commitment, safety matters. Look for:
Marine calcium typically offers the best safety profile for continuous use due to its natural form and gentle digestive impact.
Where your calcium comes from significantly impacts its quality:
Best: Marine-derived calcium from algae
Good: Plant-derived calcium
Basic: Limestone-derived calcium
Avoid:
Marine Calcium With Vitamin D3 + K2 earns the top spot because it addresses the three major problems with typical calcium supplements: poor absorption, incorrect dosing, and improper utilization.
Unlike limestone-derived calcium, this supplement sources calcium from Lithothamnion spp., a red marine algae with a unique porous structure that dramatically improves absorption.
This unique source of calcium has been studied to:
The optimal 500mg dose per serving helps to maximize absorption, as research shows that calcium uptake declines with higher doses. With this calculated serving size, you’ll be able to get more usable calcium without waste.
What truly sets this formula apart is the addition of two critical nutrients most calcium supplements lack:
This supplement also provides over 70 naturally occurring trace minerals from marine algae that work together to not just maintain but actually improve bone density over time, as demonstrated in clinical studies. ³
With both a natural, well-tolerated form of calcium and booster vitamins, this formula proves to be the safest and most absorbable out of all.
The Bone & Stress Essentials Bundle earns our second-place ranking by solving a problem most calcium supplements ignore: the crucial balance between calcium and magnesium. While our top pick excels for calcium supplementation alone, this bundle provides the perfect partnership of both essential minerals.
Did you know that calcium without sufficient magnesium can actually reduce the benefits of your calcium supplement?
Taking calcium without proper magnesium is like building a house with only a framework and no foundation – it won’t provide the stability you need. When out of balance, these minerals compete for absorption pathways, potentially limiting how much calcium actually reaches your bones.
This bundle solves that by providing both minerals in the perfect amounts – a 2:1 ratio of calcium to magnesium that matches what your body naturally needs. Research shows this balanced approach helps:
Additionally, the bundle includes strategic vitamin additions that many competitors completely overlook:
For those concerned with comprehensive bone health and overall wellbeing, this bundle provides a complete mineral system that works in harmony with your body’s natural processes.
Get Maximum Bone Support
Trust What You’re Taking
Feel the Difference Daily
Get The Perfect Pair for Better Health
Save While Getting More
Feel Better All Around
AlgaeCal is a plant-based calcium supplement that’s marketed to support bone health.
The type of calcium used in AlgaeCal is marine calcium, which we absolutely love. Their formula also contains vitamin D3 as a booster, along with magnesium as well.
Now, even though we like the clean ingredients and great formulation, we’re not too excited about them not including vitamin K into the mix, as it’s a must-have to prevent calcium deposits in unwanted areas like your arteries.
All in all, a pretty good choice for a calcium supplement only if you’ve got the budget for it, as it costs significantly more than the other choices in this list.
Citracal is a calcium with vitamin D3 supplement that’s marketed to provide essential nutrients for bone health.
Citracal’s calcium type is a mix of calcium citrate and calcium carbonate, which are harder to absorb and may cause more side effects compared to marine calcium. It also contains a dose of vitamin D, which aids in calcium absorption.
Now, we do love the vitamin booster they’ve added, but we’re definitely not fans of the amount of fillers and colors they’ve added to the ingredients, which include talc, titanium dioxide, and magnesium stearate.
Caltrate is a calcium supplement that’s marketed for bone health as well.
The ingredient blend is simple, with 600 mg of calcium with absorbability booster vitamin D. Now, Caltrate uses calcium carbonate, which is the least absorbable type of calcium. Plus, you may experience side effects like an upset stomach or constipation.
Now, while we do appreciate them adding vitamin D to ensure you get the best from the calcium, we’re not too happy about the other ingredients they’ve added.
Even with its affordable price tag, it doesn’t justify having fillers like talc, titanium dioxide, and other food coloring like Red 40 that do not offer any benefits to the formula.
Calcium and magnesium work as partners in your body. They share many of the same pathways and support over 300 biochemical processes together.
Taking both minerals in the right ratio (about 2:1 calcium to magnesium) provides several advantages:
When sourced from marine origins, both minerals come with their natural cofactors intact, making them more effective together than either one alone.
The recommended daily amounts are:
However, these amounts include calcium from both food and supplements. The average diet provides about 500-700mg daily, so most people need roughly 500-700mg from supplements.
Taking more than 1,500mg total daily provides no additional benefit and may increase health risks, especially without vitamin K2.
While vitamin D helps your body absorb calcium, vitamin K2 directs where that calcium goes.
Without enough K2:
K2-MK7 (the form in our top-rated supplement) is the most effective form, providing 24-hour protection with a single daily dose.
Several factors can help or hinder calcium absorption:
Helps absorption:
Hinders absorption:
4 min 35 sec
